Does Mukhtaran Mai Verdict Mean Failure for Pakistan’s Women’s Rights Movement?
June 1, 2011
In April, Mukhtaran Mai had to relive the most excruciating memory of her life when the Supreme Court of Pakistan acquitted all but one of the accused in her rape case. The decision elicited a sharp reaction from civil society groups and media organizations in Pakistan. Many people described it as a setback to the women’s right movement in the country, though it was an awfully pessimistic assessment of the situation.
Mai had fallen victim to the tribal justice system when her 12-year-old brother was accused of having an illicit relationship with a girl from an influential clan in a small village community. The boy never got a fair trial, yet it was his sister who was ultimately subjected to retributive justice by an informal village council that asked a group of men to sexually abuse her.
Mai’s reaction to such humiliation surprised everyone in her community. Rather than staying silent, she decided to fight back in one of the world’s most conservative social milieus. Her case was taken up by local media outlets and civil society organizations. It was also covered by leading international journalists who were instrumental in bringing global attention to one of the most heinous episodes of violence against women in Pakistan.
As time went on, Mai emerged as the face of the women’s right movement in Pakistan. She managed to release a book, making the facts of her case known to the world, and opened a school in her town, thinking that illiteracy was the underlying cause for tragedies such as the one that she had suffered. Her case became extremely high-profile. But does its unfortunate outcome amount to the failure of women’s right movement in Pakistan, as many here are saying?
It is clear that Mai and many other women like her have suffered extreme injustice. But it is not right to assume this verdict is a benchmark to measure overall progress of Pakistan’s larger women’s movement –a movement that originally emerged in the 1980s to reclaim the rights of millions of women in the face of state oppression and General Ziaul Haq’s Islamization program.
That movement has come a long way since its beginning. It was launched by a handful of highly-qualified and enterprising women who were sometimes misunderstood even by other female members of society. Today, despite setbacks like Mai’s horrific case, thousands more women and men continue to become the torchbearers in the women’s movement. They have worked on gender issues in Pakistan, fought against discriminatory legislation, advocated for reducing gender-based violence at all levels of society, and pushed for laws that are imperative for the welfare of women in their country.
The recently approved Sexual Harassment Act, the restoration of women’s reserved seats in the national and provincial assemblies, and the inclusion of gender issues of vital importance into the manifestos of all leading political parties are some of the examples where the movement has generated concrete results. It has also galvanized the masses against social taboos like the qisas and diyat laws, the controversial Hudood Ordinance, voting rights of women, and peasant land rights. Such developments have provided a platform for women to fight for their rights, and mobilized other groups to become active on issues related to women.
In some ways, one can even sense the progress of these efforts by looking again at the Mukhtaran Mai case: not long ago, sexual assaults of similar nature were most often simply swept under the carpet in Pakistan. But Mai’s case was brought dramatically to the forefront and all effort was made to help her get justice. Also, the widespread outrage that followed the court verdict clearly reflected that people were aware of her plight and expected serious punishment for the perpetrators of the crime. This increased awareness around justice is particularly significant, because the women’s rights movement in Pakistan has been primarily about educating the masses on significant gender issues and changing their mindsets over the long term.
The outcome of Mukhtaran Mai’s case was undeniably tragic. And it also serves as a major setback to the overall justice system of the country. But it does not spell the undoing of the entire women’s movement in Pakistan. It is, however, sadly ironic that the legal community that, until recently, was fighting for its own rights failed miserably to protect the rights of a woman who belongs to a small village community in Punjab and has valiantly fought for justice in her country.
Nadia Tariq Ali is The Asia Foundation’s senior program officer for the Gender Equity Program in Pakistan. She can be reached at [email protected]. The views and opinions expressed here are those of the individual author and not those of The Asia Foundation or the Gender Equity Program.
About our blog, In AsiaIn Asia is a weekly in-depth, in-country resource for readers who want to stay abreast of significant events and issues shaping Asia\’s development, hosted by The Asia Foundation. Drawing on the first-hand insight of over 70 renowned experts in over 20 countries, In Asia delivers concentrated analysis on issues affecting each region of Asia, as well as Foundation-produced reports and polls.
In Asia is posted and distributed every Wednesday evening, Pacific Time and is accessible via email and RSS. If you have any questions, please send an email to [email protected].
ContactFor questions about In Asia, or for our cross-post and re-use policy, please send an email to [email protected].
The Asia Foundation
465 California St., 9th Floor
San Francisco, CA 94104
PO Box 193223
San Francisco, CA 94119-3223
THE LATEST ACROSS ASIA
The Asia Foundation Partners with MasterCard and Vietnam Bank for Social Policies on Mobile Banking Service
February 23, 2017
The Power of the Political Voice: Women as Voters, Candidates and Activists
Wednesday, March 22, 2017
Better Legal Education Key to Strengthening Rule of Law in Afghanistan
February 22, 2017
Six Stories, Six Paths to Development Online Platforms as Drivers of Inclusive Growth
February 20, 2017
Asia Foundation Releases Paper: Online Platforms as Drivers of Inclusive Growth
February 20, 2017
President Trump and the Future of US-Asia Relations: A View from the West Coast
Tuesday, March 7, 2017
Asian Views on America's Role in Asia
Recommendations for the Incoming U.S. President on Policy Towards Asia