Herat Dialogue Raises Tough Questions on Afghanistan’s Security
November 6, 2013
On Oct. 5-6, 2013, The Asia Foundation sent a delegation to participate in the second Herat Security Dialogue, an annual international event organized by the Afghan Institute for Strategic Studies (AISS). The dialogue brings domestic, regional, and international security experts and officials together in the historic town of Herat to discuss Afghanistan’s security in a regional and global context.
This year, nearly 150 representatives, including government officials, international organization delegates, legislators, members of academia, media, and civil society from over 30 countries participated in eight different closed door, off-the-record sessions which covered the topics of 2014 presidential elections and the transformation decade; state of regional counterterrorism cooperation; counterdrug trafficking cooperation: seeking a blueprint; regional cooperation: opportunities & obstacles; inclusive security: cosmopolitan community, Islamic Sufism; Nowruz – from shared cultural heritage toward political and economic cooperation & integration; the Afghan peace process; and prospects of Iran-Afghanistan-U.S. cooperation.
The Herat Security Dialogue’s main objective is to address a clear domestic and regional need for a permanent forum where different stakeholders could engage in dialogue aimed at building confidence and identifying practical and broader security cooperation at different levels. The Dialogue challenges conventional approaches to security and encourages creative and “out of the box thinking” and solutions. Below are some of the main findings and recommendations from this year’s Dialogue.
2014 Elections and the Transformation Decade
The importance of the upcoming elections in Afghanistan, scheduled to be held on April 5, 2014, can hardly be overstated. Despite the disqualification late last month of 16 presidential candidates and an overall time consuming and cumbersome process that has led some to question whether the nation will be ready, participants in the dialogue strongly recommended that the proposed date of the elections should not be changed or postponed. They argued that preparations have already been made, budget allocations approved, election guidelines and laws are in place, and voter registration has been ongoing. In addition, for elections to succeed, panelists agreed that the elections must be Afghan-led with the international community keeping a distance from the public eye.
Panelists also emphasized the need for candidates themselves to make greater effort during their campaigns to promote national unity, emphasize transparency, and promote women’s participation in order to avoid violations of human rights and ensure that a fair election can take place. One panelist suggested that successful elections in Afghanistan could in fact undermine the credibility of rogue factions. Another panelist representing the European Union emphasized that whoever wins, they will only be accepted by the international community under the conditions that the elections are free and fair and that a legitimate government is formed. The future president and government, however, should also be willing to cooperate with the international community and the region.
State of Regional Counterterrorism Cooperation
The Afghan National Army (ANA) cooperates with the International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) on a daily basis with the goal of enhancing the security of Afghan citizens. Yet, dialogue participants said that international and regional cooperation against terrorism needs to be strengthened dramatically, given Afghanistan’s lack of a track record in this area. According to one panelist, terrorism in the region continues to rise and grow, and he pointed out specific social, cultural, political, and psychological factors that would have to be considered in strengthening cooperation in a complex landscape, including ideology, ethnicity, religion, nationalism, separatist aspirations, weak governance, and weak institutions. He even posed the question to the audience, asking how the international community plans to prevent the new generation of terrorists from growing. In order to decrease terrorist incidents around the globe and, particularly, in the region, he concluded that the international community needs to be very much involved in answering this question, and soon. Another panelist pointed out that information-sharing among intelligence agencies needs to increase, an international consensus on the working definition of terrorism needs to be reached, public awareness needs to be raised, border cooperation needs to be strengthened, and support for democracy, dialogue, and communication needs to be promoted. All panelists agreed that Afghanistan lacks effective policies related to combatting terrorism, making regional and international cooperation all the more necessary.
Counterdrug Trafficking Cooperation
Afghanistan has one of the highest growth rates of drug addicts, estimated at over 1 million users, and is the world’s largest producer of opium, which remains the biggest source of income for Afghans, particularly in impoverished areas. In the past year, poppy production has increased in comparison to previous years, and this is mainly due to high unemployment and lack of employment opportunities. The largest opium cultivating provinces include Helmand and Kandahar, or provinces which remain unstable and unsafe. On the other hand, provinces that are relatively secure, experience no drug problems. According to the former governor of Helmand province, in 2011, the poppy cultivation in Helmand increased by 40 percent, despite joint efforts from the government and international community partners to eradicate poppy fields, no silver bullet tactic has proven effective. Moreover, poppy farmers whose fields have been destroyed during eradication efforts in many cases either join the insurgents or return to growing poppies after the dust has settled. If Afghanistan stands alone, panelists warned, it might prove difficult to fight drug trafficking. Panelists concluded that coordinating with regional neighbors, namely Iran, Pakistan, Russia, and Uzbekistan as well as with the international community, is crucial in order to find effective counter narcotics strategies and policies.
Regional Cooperation: Opportunities and Obstacles
Afghanistan is located in one of the most complex regions in the world, which can be both an asset and liability. Security in Afghanistan remains one of the biggest challenges for its neighbors. Panelists cited insecurity as a main factor responsible for decreasing incentives between Afghanistan and the region for trade and economic opportunities, which is important for the country’s political stability and social peace. According to one panelist from Tajikistan, the primary focus should be on providing alternatives by promoting vocational training in all of the country’s 34 provinces. Afghanistan has the natural resources, however, it needs the markets. Creating economic, education, and cultural opportunities between Afghanistan and its neighbors and understanding the region’s vision of the future, will lead to more stability and prosperity. As Afghanistan charts its own course and prepares for elections in six months, cooperation with its neighbors and the region will be more critical than ever.
Petra Dunne is a project manager at The Asia Foundation’s office in Kabul, Afghanistan. She can be reached at [email protected]. The views and opinions expressed here are those of the individual author and not those of The Asia Foundation.
About our blog, In AsiaIn Asia is a weekly in-depth, in-country resource for readers who want to stay abreast of significant events and issues shaping Asia's development, hosted by The Asia Foundation. Drawing on the first-hand insight of over 70 renowned experts in over 20 countries, In Asia delivers concentrated analysis on issues affecting each region of Asia, as well as Foundation-produced reports and polls.
In Asia is posted and distributed every Wednesday evening, Pacific Time and is accessible via email and RSS. If you have any questions, please send an email to [email protected].
ContactFor questions about In Asia, or for our cross-post and re-use policy, please send an email to [email protected].
The Asia Foundation
465 California St., 9th Floor
San Francisco, CA 94104
PO Box 193223
San Francisco, CA 94119-3223
THE LATEST ACROSS ASIA
Asia Foundation Releases Bangladesh Democracy Survey
August 25, 2016
Despite Opposition, K-12 Education Reform Moves Forward in the Philippines
August 24, 2016
Supporting Low-Skilled Labor in the New Lower-Middle Income Cambodia
August 24, 2016
In India New Charter Calls on Men and Boys to Counter Violence Against Women
August 24, 2016