INASIA

Insights and Analysis

Thailand and Taxes

April 15, 2015

By John J. Brandon

Today is tax day in the United States, a date many Americans dread whether they owe Uncle Sam or think they have paid too much already. April 15th always reminds me of the first time I had to pay income tax in Thailand. It was 1979, and I was employed by the Thai government teaching English in Bangkok. I had been working at the university for a year when I was told that I needed to go the administration building “immediately” to pay my income tax to the Royal Thai government. I had worked throughout high school and college, and I had always received a full tax refund because I had never made enough money. In Bangkok, my salary was 9,000 baht per month (about $450). The average Thai at that time made about $588 a year. My salary was enormous. How much would I owe?

I arrived at the administration building and announced that I had come to pay my income tax. The woman behind the counter paged methodically through a ledger, searching for my name. With dread, I awaited what she would find. Finally, she said slowly, “John, you owe 53 baht.” At that time, 53 baht was worth $2.65. To my great relief, this was a tax payment I could make right then and there. My taxes after that were always about the same: I don’t think I ever paid more than 60 baht ($3.00). I realize now, whenever I pay taxes in the U.S. (as I did this year), that I will never have it so good again.

But in 2015, as Thailand has entered the ranks of upper-middle-income countries, the nation’s tax system needs serious restructuring. Thailand’s tax revenues today are the lowest in ASEAN. Tax revenues in 2010 were 20 percent of GDP. Five years later, they are just 17 percent, and the downward trend is projected to continue. The government is increasingly starved for revenues to support investments in infrastructure and schools, yet successive governments, whether democratic or military-led, have been unwilling to raise or levy taxes, particularly a property tax. This March, citing a sluggish economy, Prime Minister Prayuth Chan-ocha put a draft tax on land and buildings on indefinite hold, saying that it would impose too great a burden on too many people.

Many Thais, both rich and poor, are simply outside of the tax system. Just three million Thais out of 67 million regularly pay income taxes. No one likes taxes – it is human nature to try to avoid them, and many Thais do – but the greater the number of the exempt, the greater the tax management costs. This is to say nothing of the corruption factor.

Another issue for current and future Thai governments is subsidies initiated by former Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra and continued by subsequent Democrat and Puea Thai administrations. Despite a pledge by the National Council for Peace and Order to reverse these populist policies, they have yet to do so. Meanwhile, taxes remain low.

In the long term, these populist fiscal policies are simply unsustainable. For Thailand to remain competitive and strengthen its position as Southeast Asia’s manufacturing, transportation, and operations hub, it must invest – in railways, ports, roads, and other infrastructure. This investment is all the more urgent as the advent of the ASEAN Economic Community looms in December. Public-private partnerships will play an important role, but tax revenues must also grow. This will require leadership.

Big business and wealthy interests in Thailand oppose the shelved land-and-buildings tax because of uncertainty about its impact on property, retail, and hotels. Low- and middle-income Thais are also uneasy. The challenge for the government, whoever is in power, is to make a compelling case for this and other taxes. Such levies must be imposed fairly and transparently, and citizens must clearly understand how their money is being used in projects and programs that benefit all.

While I was once a direct beneficiary of Thailand’s low tax rates, we all know that for Thailand to succeed and prosper as an upper-middle-income nation, the government must have enough money to provide the goods and services that the public demands. Taxes are an important part of this equation. And like citizens worldwide, Thais have the right to a say in how their taxes are being spent. The more Thais who pay taxes, the stronger the people’s voice will be.

John J. Brandon is senior director of Regional Cooperation Programs for The Asia Foundation in Washington, D.C. He can be reached at [email protected]. The views and opinions expressed here are those of the author and not those of The Asia Foundation.

3 Comments

  1. Very insightful, John; and somehow, disturbingly uplifting. I’m coming from a country where income tax is the highest in the region. Your story had a bittersweet effect on me since we as Filipinos pay so much taxes and yet we have never had any fair returns in terms of public services, infrastructure, social services (education, health – let alone any welfare!); and to top it all off, so much of the public funds are siphoned by a scheming few.

    Yesterday a lot of my colleagues and friends outside my professional circle painfully filed their tax papers. It was a depressing sight. I kept asking myself if all that hard-earned money, which could have been spent better on our children and ageing parents, was better off paid as taxes only to enrich some greedy members of the government.

    But we are not in Denmark or Switzerland. We are in the Philippines. There’s a HUGE divide between the two models of democracy. Our taxes have sadly become a tool for oppression; and at the same time a hostage of our obligations as citizens.

    Tax – the one single word that evokes all the ills of our society back here. I wish there was a simpler way to pay our dues *AND* see it work its way back to the general public; not someone’s pockets.

    *end of rant* 🙂

  2. Wow, 9,000 baht per month in 1979 – that was monster! A government salary for teaching English at a Rajabhat University is 28,760 baht for a foreigner, which has not changed in about 16 years. I have a PhD and earn a bit more than that but you can see why Thai universities can’t compete when they pay their own staff – who don’t produce research in many cases – more and give them incremental increases every year.

    Many foreigner teachers/lecturers are stuck on similar salary levels for the rest of their career here, yes they can earn extra money working on the side, but there is a limit to how much time you have to do that. Nice article and not enough about low tax Thailand – there must be a reason why so many small to medium sized business people appear to be driving around in Mercs and BMW’s worth about £60,000 to £70,000 upwards.

  3. Nice post.

    However I strongly disagree that paying taxes improves the position of the people by default. Thais are smart and know that it is better for them to make judgement calls.

About our blog, InAsia

InAsia is a weekly in-depth, in-country resource for readers who want to stay abreast of significant events and issues shaping Asia’s development, hosted by The Asia Foundation. Drawing on the first-hand insight of over 70 renowned experts in over 20 countries, InAsia delivers concentrated analysis on issues affecting each region of Asia, as well as Foundation-produced reports and polls.

InAsia is posted and distributed every other Wednesday evening, Pacific Time. If you have any questions, please send an email to [email protected].

Contact

For questions about InAsia, or for our cross-post and re-use policy, please send an email to [email protected].

The Asia Foundation
465 California St., 9th Floor
San Francisco, CA 94104


Mailing Address:
PO Box 193223
San Francisco, CA 94119-3223