Will Justice for Sahar be the Tipping Point for Pakistan’s Rule of Law?
April 11, 2018
After four long and painful years, the parents of Sahar Batool finally got a taste of justice last month. In 2014, their seven-year-old daughter, who belonged to the Hazara minority ethnic group in Balochistan province, was raped, murdered, and left on a pile of garbage in her hometown, Quetta.
The night before the judgement, a video surfaced on social media in which Sahar’s mother made a nationwide appeal for support in her quest for justice. The much-publicized hearing brought together people from different walks of life who awaited the final decision on the case with bated breath. In a flurry of emotions, on March 20, the Anti-Terrorism Court sentenced the accused to three counts of rape, terrorism, and the murder of a minor.
The case has gripped and divided Pakistan and brought into question the country’s ability to deliver justice and protect its children. The latest reports of violent crimes in Pakistan indicate a recent drastic increase in crimes against children in Pakistan, especially of girls. Sahil, a non-profit working for child protection, recently published a detailed report revealing that over nine children are subjected to sexual violence on a daily basis across the country. This has been characterized by a rise in the disturbing trend of the sexual abuse and subsequent murder of children. At the same time, other vulnerable groups such as women, religious and ethnic minorities, persons with disabilities, and transgender people also face severe discrimination and violent acts and have little recourse to justice.
In a country where the provision of justice is often delayed (the 2017 Rule of Law Index ranked Pakistan’s criminal justice system at 81 among 113 countries), the judgement in Sahar’s case is a hopeful step in the direction of bringing the perpetrators of heinous crimes against children to justice. Pakistan’s constitution declares access to justice a fundamental right and the right to legal aid a basic right under the “due process” clause of Article 4. Article 37-D requires the State to provide “inexpensive and expeditious justice.” While constitutional provisions protect the right of the vulnerable on paper, poor implementation of the law means that many vulnerable groups still lack access to justice.
To make matters worse, Pakistan’s courts struggle with a huge backlog of cases, causing delay in their disposal, and lack a stipulated timeline for court proceedings.According to the Law and Justice Commission of Pakistan (LJCP), over 1.8 million cases are pending in the superior and district judiciaries of Pakistan.The pendency at the Supreme Court stands at 38,539 cases, 293,947 with the five high courts (Islamabad, Sindh, Lahore, Peshawar, and Balochistan) and 1,869,886 cases with the subordinate judiciary of the four provinces and the federal capital. While there are multiple causes for the provision of justice being delayed in Pakistan, for Quetta specifically, a 2016 terrorism suicide attack at a hospital that claimed more than 70 lives has further stalled efforts to overhaul the justice system. Given that the fatalities were mainly advocates, Quetta’s judicial process was deeply affected, resulting in multiple protests by lawyers and bar council members around the province.
While the government has begun to introduce systems that provide access to legal aid, including the District Legal Empowerment Committees (DLECs), they are not fully functional, and those that do exist suffer from a lack of strategic management which has led to many centers becoming defunct. There is also a dearth of monitoring mechanisms to ensure their optimum functioning. Moreover, there is a lack of awareness on the part of those seeking justice, which further leads to poor access to justice.
However, there are signs that this is changing. Over the last decade, Pakistan has seen an increase in rule of law programs working on things like provision of free legal aid, strengthening judicial institutes, capacity building of law enforcement agencies with a focus on human rights and gender equity, and alternate dispute resolution. Since 2014, The Asia Foundation’s “Access to Justice for Vulnerable Populations in Pakistan” program has provided free-of-cost legal aid to three groups of vulnerable communities in 13 districts of Pakistan: persons with disabilities, survivors of gender-based violence, and ethnic and religious minorities. Sahar’s case was one among 1,422 cases managed by these legal aid centers.
The causes for the inequitable access to justice are deeply rooted, not only in existing legal frameworks but also linked to the imbalance within socio-economic power structures. A robust and inclusive legal structure requires the collaboration of the judiciary, policymakers, media, and civil society organizations (CSOs). New avenues that provide speedy justice, such as alternate dispute resolution (ADR), need to be mainstreamed into the country’s judicial system. Additionally, sustained outreach campaigns that include community engagement and awareness-raising programs will help to facilitate greater buy-in for legal reform to improve recourse to justice for the vulnerable.
Farva Rashid Minhas is a program coordinator and Abbas Hussain a program officer in The Asia Foundation’s Pakistan office. The views and opinions expressed here are those of the authors and not those of The Asia Foundation or its funders.
About our blog, InAsiaInAsia is a weekly in-depth, in-country resource for readers who want to stay abreast of significant events and issues shaping Asia\’s development, hosted by The Asia Foundation. Drawing on the first-hand insight of over 70 renowned experts in over 20 countries, InAsia delivers concentrated analysis on issues affecting each region of Asia, as well as Foundation-produced reports and polls.
InAsia is posted and distributed every Wednesday evening, Pacific Time and is accessible via email and RSS. If you have any questions, please send an email to email@example.com.
ContactFor questions about InAsia, or for our cross-post and re-use policy, please send an email to firstname.lastname@example.org.
The Asia Foundation
465 California St., 9th Floor
San Francisco, CA 94104
PO Box 193223
San Francisco, CA 94119-3223
HIGHLIGHTS ACROSS ASIA
Asia Foundation and Asian Development Bank Launch Publication on Women’s Entrepreneurship in Asia and the Pacific
October 18, 2018
The Asia Foundation Releases Report on Emerging Internet Technologies and Policy in the Philippines
October 17, 2018
ASEAN as the Architect for Regional Development Cooperation
Advancing ASEAN centrality & catalyzing action for sustainable development